Reimagining Streets, Not Roads

by Jason Packenham.

Farrells-sc-st

Green, smart, complete. Credit: WSP Parsons Brinckerhoff and Farrells.

Urban leaders are reimagining Australia’s future cities, starting with Streets 2.0 – a cross-disciplinary forum held in Sydney – with the conversation to continue in March at the Cities 4.0 Summit in Melbourne.

With autonomous vehicles on the horizon, now is the time for such events. Provocative discussions at Streets 2.0 raised as many questions as answers.

In continuing this provocation, this piece is as much a recap as it is a wondering of where to from here.

What do we mean by the street? What role do streets play in our cities today? What do we want and need from them?

Looking forward, what is their role in a future with autonomous vehicles? How do we achieve some of the grand visions of Streets 2.0? Are they possible? And if not, what needs to change?

A road and a street – what’s the difference?

Roads and streets are often confused, with negative consequences for the public domain of our cities.

A ‘road’ is a right of way between two points, prioritising thoroughfare (primarily for vehicles) over amenity.

A ‘street’ is a place in its own right. It is for all users and transport modes, and encompasses all that occurs building-to-building; including the building fronts themselves.

The opening discussion of Streets 2.0 saw mention of Austroads, Australia’s national design standards for roads, and there was general consensus on how inappropriate its application is for dense urban environments.

If roads and streets are two different things, don’t our streets — among the most economically, environmentally and socially sustainable places in our cities — deserve their own design standards?

So, where is Austreets?

Such a standard would enable a holistic, building-to-building design approach to ensure our streets are concerned with more than just the free movement of motor vehicles.

Australian city streets desperately need national design standards — binding ones — tailored for urban environments to ensure road designers are working towards a standard of holistic street design, rather than being bound by road design standards.

Such a standard would shift the focus from auto-centric design to a more inclusive framework for pedestrians, cyclists, mass transit and private motor vehicles.

And, as a number of speakers touched on at Streets 2.0, these standards are needed now to pre-empt the arrival of autonomous vehicles in the near future.

How do we design for autonomous vehicles?

Autonomous vehicles will change the way we build and live in our cities, potentially impacting urban form as much as the mass production of the Model T Ford did a century ago.

But as Smart Cities Council ANZ Executive Director Adam Beck observes, urban leaders and thinkers have been largely absent from this forum.

There a few reasons to be wary of the rollout of autonomous vehicles by the motor and technology industries if left unchecked.

One, the potential further sprawling of the urban fringe, or the rise of so-called Carmageddon where autonomous vehicles are sent driverless across the city, doubling the number of car trips our road systems need to cope with.

While autonomous vehicles undoubtedly have their place in the future city, do we know why? What problems are we attempting to solve with autonomous vehicles? And in doing so, what new problems do we create?

As was importantly raised by the Streets 2.0 discussion panel, we need to know what the question is before proposing that autonomous vehicles are the answer.

Complete Streets For Niagara, visualisation.

Complete Streets For Niagara, visualisation.

So, what is our question?

Are we pursuing safer streets? A binding national design standard tailored specifically for urban streets would go a long way to achieving this.

Are we pursuing improved urban mobility? Steven Burgess, self-styled Reformed Traffic Engineer, raised a telling point on the potential of autonomous vehicles as a solution.

He says we would simply reinforce one of the most wasteful, inefficient and environmentally damaging forms of land use and transportation — the private motor vehicle.

Whatever the role for autonomous vehicles in the future city and shared economy, strong, people-first policies and standards are needed to ensure autonomous vehicles take their rightful place in the future street.

But where are all the Steves?

Steven Burgess made perhaps one of the most notable points of the day — traffic engineers will play the pivotal role in introducing autonomous vehicles to the future street. Yet, there was a noticeable absence of traffic engineers at Streets 2.0.

Urban leaders, thinkers and designers will need to better align themselves with traffic engineers if they are to influence the future street.

On that note, perhaps Streets 2.1 can involve the Australian Institute of Traffic Management and Planning?

How do we deliver the Streets 2.0 vision?

The goals drawn from Streets 2.0 are only as good as the design standards, project briefs and budgets that enable them.

To achieve these goals, urban leaders need to be involved in the right discussions, with relevant disciplines (road designers, traffic engineers and economists) in the room working towards a common framework.

Streets need stronger distinction from roads. This needs to be underpinned with binding policies and standards that ensure all levels of the public and private sector adhere to their objectives.

Only then will the future street be green, complete and smart.

Jason-Packenham-scJason Packenham is Senior Landscape Architect with Context.

Cover image from WSP Parsons Brinckerhoff and Farrells White Paper, on autonomous vehicles in the UK.

If you would like to contribute an opinion piece, please contact StreetChat at editor@streetfurniture.com


make an enquiry

Opening hours are from Monday to Friday, 9am to 5pm.

enquire now

recent news

Join Us For Tea Time (via Zoom)

Take a quick (and educational) tea break with us! Customers are invited to book in a 10-minute Zoom chat to learn about new products. Presentations are guaranteed no longer than 10-minutes plus Q&A. Choose from: New Linea additions (recommended). Wood Without Worry. Or request a custom presentation. Each participant will receive a T2 gift box (optional). Book by contacting us on teatime@streetfurniture.com, or via the button below. Win a Georg Stool by Skagerak Tea Time bookings for Australian customers from 2 November 2021 will go into a draw for a chance to win an iconic Georg Stool by Scandinavian designer Skagerak, valued at $615. The prize will be drawn on 1 April 2022 and the winner notified by email. Ts and Cs: Presentations must be done by 1 April 2022. For customers based in …

  • 25 sep 2020
read more

In Profile: Kylie Legge, CEO of Place Score

A leading voice in placemaking, Kylie Legge is an architecture graduate, planner, place maker, author, facilitator, curator and entrepreneur. She is founding Director of Place Partners, a multidisciplinary placemaking consultancy based in Sydney, Australia and Place Score – the world’s first place experience measurement company. How did you get started and find your unique career pathway? My career has tended to veer off the beaten track. I’ve never been too worried about what other people think and am risk-hungry. I’m also interested in disruption – looking for better ways of doing things. At 23 as an architecture grad I talked my way into an internship at the Museum of Modern Art in New York. I lived a double life, working in a dive bar by night and at the most …

  • 26 apr 2022
read more

Book launch: CM+ celebrates 40 years of …urban thinking

Bill Morrison and Darrel Conybeare, co-founders and directors of Street Furniture Australia, are celebrating 40 years of design practice with their architecture and urban design studio, CM+. The two young architects, shaped by formative experiences in the US and UK working with major players such as Eames, William Holford & Partners and the Farrell/Grimshaw Partnership – started their own venture in 1980 to shape cities through the still-fledgling practice of urban design. Their work includes the redesign of Macquarie Street and Circular Quay in Sydney for the 1988 Bicentennial, designing prominent Canberra spaces such as City Walk, universities in China and Kuching Waterfront in Malaysia. Bill and Darrel’s philosophy considers how a design might discover a the urban pulse and heritage of a city, reveal its urban character, and recognise …

  • 19 may 2022
read more

related news

In Profile: Linda Corkery

StreetChat interviews new AILA National President Linda Corkery. Linda is a highly respected landscape architect with a trifecta portfolio of responsibility: AILA National President, Associate Professor at UNSW and Director of Corkery Consulting. We chat about AILA, the future of cities and how women are faring in her industry. Can you tell us about your journey, from the US to Hong Kong, to Australia? My journey to landscape architecture started at Cornell University in upstate New York. At Cornell, I completed master degrees in urban and regional planning and in landscape architecture. There were a few international students in the program, including an Australian fellow I got to know quite well, Noel Corkery. I finished my studies and headed to Chicago, working first in an urban planning consultancy and then in …

  • 23 jan 2017
read more

Refugees Welcome Hatch Seat

Nicholas Camerer’s prize-winning Hatch Seat is the new centrepiece of a community garden for Karen refugees. Street Furniture Australia manufactured the seat as part of the Intergrain Urban Timber Project competition, which challenged graduate and student landscape architects to design a meaningful piece for the Historic Farm Precinct in Victoria. The resurrected kitchen garden is a place for Karen refugees from Burma to learn new skills and share their culture, the result of a volunteer program by Parks Victoria and Werribee Park in partnership with AMES (Adult Multicultural Education Services). Camerer’s design features red, white and blue panels to represent the colours of both the Karen and Australian flags. Robust timber cross beams double as a leaning rack for gardening tools when not in use as a seat. The landscape architect, from …

  • 18 jan 2017
read more

How Streets 2.0 Will Think Tank Future Cities

Our streets, and our cities, are due for an overhaul, says Adam Beck, but strong collaboration is needed to secure all the working parts. The Executive Director of the Smart Cities Council for Australia and New Zealand will coordinate Streets 2.0, a forum inviting engineers, landscape architects, planners, architects, technologists and policy makers to take part in Sydney on December 6. “Streets 2.0 is a critical discussion the industry has to have,” Beck tells StreetChat. “When streets consume up to 20 to 30 per cent of the land area of our cities and communities, it is worth making them function as sustainably as possible. “Our streets are public spaces. Is the best use of space to fill them with two-tonne metal machines travelling at 60 kilometres an hour?” With ideas …

  • 16 nov 2016
read more